Why daylight and sunlight matter in planning
Cities are being asked to deliver more homes on less land. That
produces taller, deeper buildings on tighter plots, frequently
alongside two and three storey residential stock that has never had
anything substantial next to it.
Daylight and sunlight is one of the few places where that tension can be measured. It
turns a discussion about character and scale into a set of figures
that officers, objectors and committees can engage with, and it has
become one of the considerations most often examined in detail on
schemes of any density.
Two separate assessments
A daylight and sunlight report answers two distinct questions, and
keeping them apart matters.
The first is the effect of the proposed development on the amenity
of neighbouring properties. That is assessed using
VSC, NSL and APSH, and it is the part most likely to attract comment
from neighbours and objectors.
The second is the quality of daylight within the
proposed accommodation. Since the 2022 edition of the guidance that
is assessed against BS EN 17037, which offers either a daylight
factor method or a climate-based illuminance method, in place of the
average daylight factor approach used previously. For compact
typologies such as co-living, student accommodation and build to
rent, this is often the more commercially significant of the two,
and the one where design input at
concept stage pays back most.
The guidance calls for interpretation
The BRE guide states plainly that its numerical criteria are not
intended to be applied rigidly, and that they should be interpreted
flexibly according to context. A result below a stated value is
therefore not automatically a failure: it is a finding that needs to
be understood against the character of the area, the existing
condition and the planning objectives for the site.
That interpretation still has to be evidenced. An argument that
context justifies a departure carries weight where the departure has
been quantified, the context has been set out, and the relevant
guidance has been cited with its reference. We write reports on the
basis that they will be reviewed in detail, because on schemes of
any scale they usually are.