Rights of Light

Section 203 explained: appropriation, and when it protects a scheme

Where the statutory conditions are met, Section 203 converts the right to an injunction into a right to compensation. When the route is open, and when not.

Where it is available, Section 203 is one of the most effective ways of managing rights of light risk, however it is often considered too late in a scheme to be used.

It does not apply to every site, and a developer cannot invoke it on their own. Where it is available, however, it changes the basis of the negotiation, because it removes the adjoining owner’s ability to stop the scheme, which is the main source of their negotiating position.

The problem it solves

A right of light is a private property right, and the primary remedy for interference with a property right in English law is an injunction. It is the injunction, rather than the compensation, that gives rights of light its commercial weight.

A neighbour who can credibly threaten to stop a development is, in practice, negotiating over the value of the developer’s programme as well as the value of their lost light. The second figure is usually much larger, and it is set by how much the scheme is worth to the developer rather than by how much light the neighbour has lost.

Section 203 breaks the link between the threat of an injunction and the price of a release.

What it does

Section 203 of the Housing and Planning Act 2016 replaced the earlier provision at Section 237 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.

Where land has been appropriated for planning purposes by a qualifying authority, and the statutory conditions are satisfied, building or maintenance work carried out on that land may proceed even though it interferes with a third party right such as an easement of light.

The right itself is not extinguished. What changes is the remedy. The neighbour retains a claim, and that claim is for compensation, assessed broadly by reference to the diminution in value of their property. What they no longer have is the ability to obtain an injunction.

Practically, the settlement conversation moves from “what will it take to let this scheme proceed” to “what has this cost you”. Those are different questions and can produce materially different figures, particularly on a constrained central site.

Who can use it

The power belongs to qualifying authorities, not to developers. A private developer cannot appropriate its own land.

The route that is used in practice involves a local authority, or another qualifying body such as certain public corporations, acquiring or already holding the land, appropriating it for planning purposes, and then disposing of it to the developer. The Section 203 protection passes with the land to the successor in title.

In practice, the developer’s main task is persuading a public body that this is an appropriate use of a statutory power, on a scheme that delivers something the authority wants.

What an authority will want to see

Every authority approaches this differently and you should take advice specific to the body concerned. Broadly, expect to have to demonstrate:

  • That the development delivers a clear planning benefit, which usually means the things sitting in the local plan: housing numbers, affordable provision, regeneration, employment floorspace.
  • That planning permission is in place or is realistically forthcoming.
  • That reasonable attempts have been made to deal with affected parties directly. Section 203 is not intended as a substitute for negotiating.
  • That the compensation liability is understood, quantified and secured, so the authority is not exposed.
  • That the statutory conditions are met on the facts of the site.

The last two are where our work sits. An authority is being asked to take a decision with a compensation liability attached to it, and the quality of the technical evidence behind the exposure figure has a significant bearing on how comfortable they are.

Why it has to start early

Section 203 involves a process that takes time. It requires the authority to form a view, a decision that will normally require a committee, legal agreements between the parties, and an appropriation that has to be properly made.

Schemes that begin exploring it once neighbours have already instructed solicitors are in a much weaker position. The authority is being asked to act in the middle of a live dispute rather than as part of an orderly delivery strategy, and the timetable rarely fits the developer’s programme.

The route is not open simply because a scheme involves a council or another public body. It depends on how the land is held, whether a qualifying authority has acquired or appropriated it and on what basis, whether planning permission is in place for the works, and whether the works relate to the purpose for which the land was acquired or appropriated. Those are legal questions on which site-specific advice is needed. Where the land history suggests the conditions might be met, it is worth testing at feasibility rather than at pre-construction.

Where it fits alongside everything else

Section 203 is one of several routes, and most schemes use more than one. The others are designing the injury out, negotiating releases, placing insurance, and cutting back the element causing the injury.

The point of taking advice early is to establish which of them are realistically open, because their availability changes as a scheme progresses. An approach to neighbouring owners can affect what insurance cover is available and on what terms, so the sequence should be coordinated with specialist insurance advice from the start. Section 203 involves a process that takes time, and becomes harder to accommodate once the programme is well advanced.

We set out how these fit together on our rights of light page. If you have a site where a public body has an interest, it is worth a conversation early rather than late.

This is general commentary rather than legal advice. Whether the statutory conditions are met on a particular site is a legal question, and one that needs site-specific advice.

Sources

Questions we are asked about this

What does Section 203 do?

Where land has been appropriated for planning purposes by a qualifying authority, and the statutory conditions are met, Section 203 permits building work that interferes with a third party right such as a right of light. The neighbour’s remedy becomes compensation rather than an injunction. The right is not extinguished, however the remedy for interfering with it changes.

Does Section 203 mean the neighbour gets nothing?

No. Compensation remains payable, assessed broadly on a diminution in value basis. What changes is that the neighbour cannot stop the development, which removes their ability to price a release by reference to the negotiating position an injunction threat gives them.

Can a private developer use Section 203?

Not directly. The power sits with qualifying authorities. In practice a private developer works with a local authority or other qualifying body, which appropriates the land and then disposes of it, with the Section 203 protection passing to the successor in title. It is a structured transaction rather than a form to fill in.

How long does it take?

Long enough that it needs to start early. It involves the authority satisfying itself that the statutory tests are met, a decision-making process that will normally go to committee, and legal documentation between the parties. Treating it as a late fallback is the most common way schemes lose the option.

Send us a site and we will give you a preliminary view.

A location, a massing model and an outline programme are usually enough for a high-level desktop assessment, which we provide free of charge and with no obligation to instruct.

Or call 020 8191 4207

  1. Send us the site A location and whatever drawings or massing you have.
  2. A preliminary review of the site within 24 hours Free of charge, with no obligation to instruct.

Discuss your project

Send us the site and we will come back with a preliminary review within 24 hours, free of charge and with no obligation to instruct.

A postcode is enough for a first look.

What is proposed, the stage it has reached and the advice you need. Two or three sentences is plenty.

Drawings or a massing model (optional)

or drop them here

    Up to three files, 8 MB in total. Plans, sections, a PDF or a model file are all useful. For anything larger, email contact@mdxsurveyors.com or send a link.

    We use what you send here to respond to your enquiry and nothing else. See our privacy notice.

    Would you rather talk it through? Call 020 8191 4207 or email contact@mdxsurveyors.com.

    Call Discuss your project