Development Risk

How rights of light affect development value

How rights of light exposure affects what a site is worth: settlement cost, lost floor area and funding. How to price it at bid stage rather than absorb it later.

Rights of light rarely stops a development outright. More often, its effect shows up in what the site is worth.

For a developer, the practical question is what the exposure does to the land value, and whether that figure is in the appraisal before exchange or only established afterwards.

Three routes into the valuation

The settlement cost. Where neighbours hold enforceable rights that the scheme would infringe, releases have to be negotiated and paid for. On a constrained central site with multiple affected owners this is a material line rather than a contingency.

The figure is not set by the technical loss alone. The strength of the claim bears on it too, and so does the stage the scheme has reached. Weaker claims tend to settle nearer book value, whereas stronger ones, particularly where a programme allows little flexibility, are more often settled by reference to the additional value the scheme achieves. The range between those is wide, which is why a figure taken from another site is of limited use.

The lost envelope. Where the exposure is severe enough that settlement looks unattractive, one option is to design the injury out. That may mean fewer storeys, a set-back or a corner removed. Each has a floor area consequence, and floor area is what the appraisal is built on.

The funding position. Where rights of light remain unresolved ahead of a start on site, funders and their advisers commonly want to see how the risk is being managed before terms are settled. That can affect conditions, timing or pricing, and how much it affects them depends on the lender, the scheme and the strength of the evidence put in front of them.

Why the number moves with time

The technical injury caused by a given massing does not change. Whether you assess it at bid stage or after the piling rig arrives, the same windows lose the same light.

What changes is the negotiating position.

At bid stage the developer has every option: adjust the massing, place insurance, approach neighbours discreetly, or walk away from the site altogether. Having those options available is what gives the developer their negotiating position, and it is reflected in the price.

By pre-construction, the massing is fixed, planning is committed, the neighbours have instructed their own surveyors, and the developer has a programme with a cost attached to every week of delay. The claim has not changed, however the price of resolving it usually has.

The case for taking advice early is therefore commercial rather than technical.

What to do at bid stage

Establish whether there is a claim at all. Not every window carries a right, and whether a particular one does has to be established rather than assumed. Section 3 of the Prescription Act 1832 refers to a dwelling house, workshop or other building, so commercial premises may benefit as readily as residential ones, and there is no requirement that the room behind the window be a habitable one. The age of a building, alterations to it, periods of obstruction and any change of use are all relevant, though none of them settles the question on its own. Establishing which neighbouring owners are likely to have a claim is often the most useful early output, because it converts a vague worry into a defined set of parties.

Quantify the realistic exposure. That means a realistic range, with the assumptions stated, rather than a worst case, and one that can be put into an appraisal and defended.

Test what removing it costs. Where the injury is concentrated in a small part of the scheme, a cutback analysis tells you what the floor area sacrifice buys in reduced exposure. On some schemes losing a corner is cheaper than settling, and on others it is not. Either way, the analysis turns the choice into a priced decision.

Consider insurance early. Sequencing matters. An approach to a neighbouring owner can affect whether cover is available and on what terms, so insurance is best considered before any approach is made and coordinated with specialist insurance advice. Where engagement with neighbours is the right strategy, agreed-conduct arrangements with an insurer can allow it on managed terms. Insurance does not extinguish the underlying right.

Consider whether Section 203 is relevant. The route is not open simply because a scheme involves a council or another public body. It depends on how the land is held, whether a qualifying authority has acquired or appropriated it and on what basis, whether planning permission is in place for the works, and whether the works relate to the purpose for which the land was acquired or appropriated. Those are legal questions needing site-specific advice. Where the land history suggests the conditions might be met, it takes time to pursue and is worth raising early. We cover it in Section 203 explained.

Pricing it into the bid

Pre-acquisition advice will not always find that a site is clean. What it allows is a bid that reflects the constraint, so the site is either won at a price that works or lost to a bidder who has not priced the risk.

Losing a site on price to a bidder who has underestimated their exposure is a reasonable outcome, and preferable to winning it at a price the scheme cannot support.

This is general commentary rather than legal or valuation advice, and the figures on any particular site depend on its own facts.

Sources

If you have a site under consideration, send it to us. A location, an intended use and a title plan is usually enough for an initial view, and we will come back with a preliminary review within 24 hours.

Questions we are asked about this

How much does a rights of light settlement typically cost?

There is no reliable typical figure, and any figure offered without sight of the site is guesswork. Settlements are informed by the extent of technical loss, the book value of the affected areas, and the strength of the claim. Weaker claims tend to settle nearer book value, whereas stronger ones, particularly where the programme allows little flexibility, are more often settled by reference to the additional value the scheme achieves.

Should rights of light risk be a line in the appraisal?

On any constrained urban site, yes. Leaving it out does not remove the cost. It moves it from a priced assumption to an unfunded one. A quantified allowance with the working behind it is also considerably easier to defend to a funder or an investment committee than a discovery halfway through.

Can we buy the site subject to a rights of light report?

Frequently, and it is a sensible structure where the seller will accept it. It is worth agreeing what the report has to conclude and what happens if it concludes something worse, because a condition that only says an assessment will be obtained does not protect you from what it finds.

Send us a site and we will give you a preliminary view.

A location, a massing model and an outline programme are usually enough for a high-level desktop assessment, which we provide free of charge and with no obligation to instruct.

Or call 020 8191 4207

  1. Send us the site A location and whatever drawings or massing you have.
  2. A preliminary review of the site within 24 hours Free of charge, with no obligation to instruct.

Discuss your project

Send us the site and we will come back with a preliminary review within 24 hours, free of charge and with no obligation to instruct.

A postcode is enough for a first look.

What is proposed, the stage it has reached and the advice you need. Two or three sentences is plenty.

Drawings or a massing model (optional)

or drop them here

    Up to three files, 8 MB in total. Plans, sections, a PDF or a model file are all useful. For anything larger, email contact@mdxsurveyors.com or send a link.

    We use what you send here to respond to your enquiry and nothing else. See our privacy notice.

    Would you rather talk it through? Call 020 8191 4207 or email contact@mdxsurveyors.com.

    Call Discuss your project