A right to light is a private legal right that allows a building to keep enough natural light through its windows for the ordinary use of the rooms behind them. It is not a right to all the light a window receives today, and it is not a right to a view, to sunshine or to light in a garden.
Most rights to light are acquired through long use. A window that has received light for twenty years or more without interruption will often have one, and it can be enforced against a neighbouring development even after that development has planning permission. That last point is the one most people do not expect, and it is why rights to light carry the commercial weight they do.
“Right to light” and “rights of light” mean the same thing. Surveyors and lawyers tend to say rights of light, and that is the term used across the rest of this site.
How is a right to light acquired?
There are three ways a building can come to have a right to light.
The first is an express grant, where a deed gives one property a right to light over another. This is less common than people assume, and deeds are as likely to take rights away as to give them, through a clause reserving a neighbour’s right to build.
The second is an implied grant, which can arise when land in common ownership is divided and one part is sold.
The third, and by far the most common, is prescription. Under section 3 of the Prescription Act 1832, light that has been enjoyed through a window for twenty years without interruption becomes an absolute right, unless it was enjoyed by written consent or agreement. The doctrine of lost modern grant reaches the same result by a different legal route and is often pleaded alongside it.
Two practical consequences follow. The right belongs to the building, not to the owner, so it does not matter how long the current owner has lived there. It also attaches to openings rather than to land, which includes rooflights and glazed doors but not gardens, yards or terraces.
Do I have a right to light?
Possibly, and the first thing to establish is the history of the window rather than the size of the development next to it.
The questions that matter are whether the window has been in the same place and at broadly the same size for twenty years, whether anything in the title or a lease restricts it, and whether the light has been interrupted in that time. A window that was enlarged ten years ago may have a right for the original opening only.
A developer can also stop a right from being acquired. Under the Rights of Light Act 1959 a light obstruction notice can be registered as a local land charge, and it acts as a notional wall in front of the window, interrupting the twenty years before they are complete.
None of this is visible from the street, which is why we check the history before giving any view on the loss.
How much light does the law protect?
Enough for the ordinary use of the room, and no more. The test comes from Colls v Home and Colonial Stores (1904), where the House of Lords held that the right is to sufficient light “according to the ordinary notions of mankind”. A neighbour cannot object to every reduction in their light, only to one that leaves a room inadequately lit.
In practice, sufficiency is measured using the Waldram method. A three-dimensional model of the buildings is used to plot, for each room, the area of the floor at table height that receives at least 0.2% of the light from the sky. That contour divides the well-lit part of the room from the rest.
The long-established convention is the 50/50 rule: a room remains adequately lit if at least half of it is well lit. Residential rooms can be held to a higher standard, following Ough v King (1967), and some surveyors look for around 55% in a home. That is a benchmark used in practice, not a fixed rule, and how much weight it carries depends on the room and its surroundings.
It is a convention rather than a rule of law, however it has been applied for over a century and it is the test both sides’ surveyors will use. It also produces results people do not expect. A room that loses a great deal of light but stays above the threshold has no claim, whilst a room that loses a small amount and drops below it may have a strong one. The size of the loss matters, however where it leaves the room matters more.
Is a right to light the same as daylight and sunlight in planning?
No, and confusing the two is the most common mistake we see on both sides.
Planning authorities assess a scheme’s effect on its neighbours using the BRE Guidelines, through tests such as the Vertical Sky Component (VSC) and the No-Sky Line (NSL). Those tests are advisory, and the decision rests with the council as a planning judgement. You can read more about how that works on our daylight and sunlight page.
A right to light sits in private property law and is decided by the courts. Planning permission does not affect it. A scheme can comply with the BRE Guidelines and still infringe a right to light, and a scheme can fall short of the BRE Guidelines and infringe no rights at all.
What happens if a development infringes a right to light?
The neighbour can ask the court for an injunction, to stop the development or to require the infringing part to be altered or removed, or for damages instead.
Injunctions are not theoretical. In Regan v Paul Properties (2006) the Court of Appeal confirmed that an injunction remains the primary remedy, and in HKRUK II (CHC) Ltd v Heaney (2010) the court ordered the removal of the infringing part of a building that had already been completed. Since Coventry v Lawrence (2014) the courts have had more flexibility to award damages instead, however the risk of an injunction has not gone away, and it is that risk which drives most settlements. Our article on rights of light injunctions covers this in more detail.
In practice very few cases reach court. Most are settled by agreement, with the developer paying compensation in return for a deed releasing the right. Compensation is usually assessed by reference to the value of the light lost, and negotiated settlements are commonly a multiple of that figure, because the neighbour is negotiating with the threat of an injunction behind them.
Timing matters for the neighbour as well. Someone who knows a development is coming and does nothing until it is built will find it much harder to obtain an injunction than someone who raised it early.
What can a developer do about rights of light?
Rights of light are best dealt with before a site is bought or a design is fixed, when the options are widest. A development can be shaped to reduce its effect on the rooms that would otherwise fall below the threshold, and the cost of the remaining risk can be built into the appraisal.
Beyond design, the main routes are negotiated releases, rights of light insurance, light obstruction notices on sites that are not yet affected, and, on the right schemes, Section 203, which replaces the neighbour’s right to an injunction with a right to compensation. Insurance is often available even where the technical losses are large, as our Liverpool case study shows.
The right strategy depends on the losses, the neighbours and the programme. Our rights of light page sets out how we approach it for developers.
Common misunderstandings
- “I have a right to my view.” There is no right to a view in English law.
- “Planning permission means the developer is safe.” It does not. Rights of light are enforced separately, and can be enforced after work has started.
- “The 45-degree rule decides it.” That is a planning rule of thumb for extensions. It has no bearing on a right to light.
- “Any loss of light is actionable.” Only a loss that leaves a room below the threshold of sufficient light is actionable.
- “My garden is protected.” A right to light benefits windows, not open land.
What should I do if I think my right to light is affected?
Act early. Send us the address and the planning reference, or any letter you have received from the developer, and we will come back with a free preliminary view within 24 hours: whether your windows are likely to have a right, and whether the development is likely to infringe it.
Where a right is affected, the developer will usually meet a neighbour’s reasonable surveyor’s fees as part of the negotiation, so taking advice need not cost you anything. Our page for neighbouring owners explains how this works.
If you are a developer, the same applies in reverse. The earlier the rights of light position is understood, the more of the options above are still open.