Residential development, Liverpool

A rights of light assessment where large technical losses did not mean large budgets, allowing the client to insure the risk and build out without negotiating with any neighbour.

Sector
Residential
Location
Liverpool
Services
Rights of Light
Status
Advisory · 2026
1,000+ sq ft
EFZ loss to the most affected neighbour

Six rooms with a potentially actionable loss

50%
Budget as a share of that property's value

A standard book value would have equalled 73% to 107%

0
Neighbours approached

The risk was insured on a wait-and-see basis

The scheme

A high-density residential development in Liverpool, rising well above the low-rise commercial buildings that surround it. The scheme had been through the planning process when we were instructed to assess the rights of light risk to the neighbouring properties and to recommend a strategy for dealing with it.

The challenge

The neighbouring buildings to the north currently enjoy light unobstructed across the Site, so given the scale of the development a significant loss of light was unavoidable. At the most affected property, six rooms would experience a potentially actionable loss, with an equivalent first zone (EFZ) loss of more than 1,000 sq ft. On a conventional book value approach, a loss of that size produces a compensation budget that would usually point a developer towards negotiating a release with each owner before starting on site.

Our role

We built a three-dimensional model of the Site and its surroundings and assessed the neighbouring properties using the Waldram method, the “50:50 rule”, calculating the change in the area of each room that receives adequate light and the resulting equivalent first zone (EFZ) loss. Only properties capable of enjoying rights of light were taken forward: those old enough to have acquired prescriptive rights under the Prescription Act 1832, or those likely to have inherited rights from an earlier building in the same position.

A building immediately to the east had been redeveloped very recently. It had not yet acquired prescriptive rights over the Site, and our review of the building it replaced showed no windows facing the Site, so no rights could have been transferred. We assessed the scheme against both the current and the historic position on that neighbouring plot to understand any cumulative effect, and the results were similar. We also recommended that the client register a Light Obstruction Notice against the new building if the Site is not developed before rights over it could mature.

Of the five neighbouring properties assessed, three would see only de minimis changes that we did not consider actionable. Two would experience potentially actionable losses, and these are where the risk lay.

Reviewing the budgets

Both affected properties are low-grade commercial and industrial buildings in a secondary location, which appeared vacant and in a significantly dilapidated condition. The most affected is a mid-terrace unit with very limited redevelopment potential, for which there would be little demand from anyone other than a buyer able to assemble the whole terrace.

We reflected this in each element of the book value calculation. A softer yield was adopted to reflect the condition and marketability of the buildings, a reduced value was applied to each square foot of light because light has limited use to vacant, low-grade accommodation, and the uplift for a negotiated release was set below the three to five times commonly adopted.

Even on that basis, the book value figure for the most affected property would have equalled between 73% and 107% of the value of the entire building, using the client’s view of its market value and a capitalisation of its potential rental income. In our opinion, a figure that values the light at or above the value of the building itself cannot be the outcome of a reasonable hypothetical negotiation. In Tamares v Fairpoint the court emphasised that damages should reflect a fair bargain and must “feel right”. Cooper v Ludgate House confirms that negotiating damages can exceed the diminution in value, however that decision concerned high-value homes and a major, profitable London development, and does not justify a ransom figure for a derelict secondary building.

We therefore proposed a budget of 50% of the upper end of the property’s market value. This has no legal precedent, and we said so in the report, however given the evidence it is a conservative figure. We also considered a share of the developer’s profit, and explained why it was not the appropriate basis for buildings of this nature and condition. The second property, with a single affected room, was budgeted on the same basis.

The strategy

The owners had not asserted their rights at any point, even though the scheme had been through planning, and the buildings showed little sign of current occupation. We assessed the risk of an injunction as low, and recommended wait-and-see insurance, with the three properties seeing de minimis changes also included in the policy schedule for completeness. We advised that no approach should be made to any owner or occupier before taking advice from the insurance broker and the client’s legal advisers, as prior contact can prejudice the availability or terms of cover.

Outcome

On the strength of the report, the client obtained a cost-effective and comprehensive rights of light insurance policy on a wait-and-see basis. It allows the client to build out the Site without negotiating with any of the adjoining owners, whilst financially indemnifying the client should any of those owners come forward at a later date.

The budgets were reasoned property by property and grounded in what the affected buildings are actually worth, rather than in the technical loss alone. That gave the client a defensible measure of the risk, and a materially lower one than the EFZ results on their own would suggest.

More case studies

All case studies

Have a scheme with a similar constraint?

Send us the site and the massing. We will tell you what the light position looks like and whether it needs work.

Or call 020 8191 4207

  1. Send us the site A location and whatever drawings or massing you have.
  2. A preliminary review of the site within 24 hours Free of charge, with no obligation to instruct.

Discuss your project

Send us the site and we will come back with a preliminary review within 24 hours, free of charge and with no obligation to instruct.

A postcode is enough for a first look.

What is proposed, the stage it has reached and the advice you need. Two or three sentences is plenty.

Drawings or a massing model (optional)

or drop them here

    Up to three files, 8 MB in total. Plans, sections, a PDF or a model file are all useful. For anything larger, email contact@mdxsurveyors.com or send a link.

    We use what you send here to respond to your enquiry and nothing else. See our privacy notice.

    Would you rather talk it through? Call 020 8191 4207 or email contact@mdxsurveyors.com.

    Call Discuss your project